Sell in May and go away. That’s what some people like to do for the summer – turn all of their investments into cash, drive out to the cottage and forget about it. Let the stock markets swoon if they must, it matters not if you’re sitting in cash.
Because stock markets and subsequently equity mutual funds do often go through a period of doldrums over the summer, the strategy at first glance may appear to make some sense, but in reality it’s not likely a very good strategy at all. Unless you’re a day trader and your time horizon is measured in weeks rather than years.
We know only a few things about stock markets for certain. One is that they go up. Another is that they go down. But over time, at least since we’ve been measuring it, the overall trend has been upward. Take the TSX Composite Index over the last 10 years for example. In July of 1999 it stood at 6984. As of the beginning of July 2009, it is over 10,000. That’s an increase of over 40 per cent. Roughly the same as the gain from the beginning of March to the beginning of June of this year, or as much as you might have achieved with a GIC over the same period of time.
But that’s looking at a ten-year period that included one of the worst stock market melt-downs of the century. What if we go back and look at other ten-year periods in history. How about the ten years ending in 2007? The return then was 8.52 per cent per year. How about 2006? 9.1 per cent annualized. We have to go all the way back to 1978’s 3.27 per cent to find a ten-year period ending with worse performance than the one we just experienced.
When you look at your account statements and want to say, “Hey, I could have done as well with a GIC,” remember two things. First, the interest earned on GICs is taxable at twice the rate of the capital gains earned by an equity fund. And secondly, you may be seeing a completely different scenario by this time next month or next year. Whatever period you want to look at simply represents a snapshot in time. It’s like pressing the pause button on your VCR and judging the whole movie based on what appears on your screen at that particular moment. Obviously there is more to the story.
So you may want to believe that it’s a good decision to sell in May and go away, but only if you’ll need to access the cash value of your investments before the end of September. If your investments are part of a long term strategy, a whole movie versus a couple of frames, what the markets do over the next couple of months isn’t really of much consequence.
On the subject of market timing, which is what the sell in May axiom is all about, Sir John Templeton, a well known investment guru probably summed it up best when he said, “Bull markets are born on pessimism, grow on skepticism, mature on optimism, and die on euphoria. The time of maximum pessimism is the best time to buy and the time of maximum optimism is the best time to sell."
WHAT’S COOKING AT BEAUJENA’S FRENCH TABLE THIS MONTH
Bruschetta Pasta. This a really fresh summery pasta dish that you could make at home. Pair it with a nice, light chianti or beaujelais.
1LB spaghetti or linguine or fettuccini
3 large tomatoes chopped
1 cup packed fresh basil chopped or ½ tsp dried basil
1/3 cup shredded Parmigiano Reggiano cheese
1/3 cup finely chopped red onion
¼ cup capers
2 tbsp olive oil
1 tbsp white wine vinegar
2 cloves of garlic minced
Salt and pepper to taste
Cook your pasta in a pot of salted water for about 8 minutes (less if you prefer el dente) and drain, reserving 1/3 cup of cooking liquid. Add tomatoes and basil to pasta. Then add the cooking liquid and the rest of the ingredients. Toss. Top with a little more cheese and serve.
Note: contrary to what one customer at the restaurant who was allergic to fish insisted, capers are not fish. They are the buds of nasturtium flowers pickled in brine.